Case Studies: Healthcare

Preventable Death – Inquest Verdict in Case of Lillian Diamond

Lillian Diamond, mother to Orlagh and Francis, and wife to Brendan, was 60 years old when she died on 29th March 2019 at the Royal Victoria Hospital.  Patrick Mullarkey of O’Reilly Stewart acted on behalf of the family of Lillian Diamond at the Inquest.

On 20th November 2026, the Coroner Anne-Louise Toal, found that Lillian’s death was “preventable”.

Lillian had a history of autoimmune haemolytic anaemia and was under the care of the Belfast Trust.  Having exhausted therapies in relation to her condition, and requiring more regular blood transfusions, Lillian agreed to an elective splenectomy on 12th March 2019 at the Mater Hospital.  She was discharged on 15th March 2019.  After discharge from inpatient care, Lillian became unwell and complained of ongoing ooze from her surgical wound, tiredness, fatigue, and shortness of breath.  Blood tests were conducted which demonstrated a significant increase in her inflammatory markers.  She attended the Royal Victoria Hospital on 27th March 2019.  Whilst there, she was assessed by an Emergency Medicine Doctor, and by a Surgeon.  Having discounted a post-surgical intra-abdominal collection, she was discharged without an explanation for her shortness of breath.

On the morning of 29th March 2019, Mrs Diamond’s condition deteriorated again, and she was conveyed, by Ambulance, to the Emergency Department at the Royal Victoria Hospital.  She underwent assessment by an Emergency Medicine Doctor and thereafter by a member of the Surgical Team.  A CT was carried out, and she was transferred to the Medical Ward whereupon her condition deteriorated, and she suffered a cardiac arrest.  She was transferred to Theatre for further resuscitation.  Sadly, the resuscitation efforts were not successful, and Lillian passed away.

The coronial Inquest in this matter proceeded between the 26th and 28th May 2026.  During the course of the Inquest the Coroner heard evidence from witnesses and experts in relation to the care provided to the Deceased, and the circumstances of her death.

In finding that Lillian’s death was “preventable”, the Coroner noted that post-operatively, the duration of thromboprophylaxis prescribed to the patient was not sufficient to address the risk of VTE in Lillian’s case.  In other words, the Coroner found that the Trust did not prescribe sufficient medication to Lillian in order to avoid the risk of clot after her elective operation.  Whilst management was in accordance with guidelines at the time, there would have been a benefit, given Lillian’s high risk of clotting in consulting the Haematology Team within the Trust before discharge.  Had that been done, the Coroner found that it was possible that the subsequent tragic events could have been prevented.

More significantly, the Coroner found that in relation to the Emergency Department attendance which occurred on 27th March 2019, this was a missed opportunity in terms of averting the patient’s death.  Her assessment, after a period of 5 hours, was 4 hours beyond the 1 hour target.  The delay was as a consequence of extreme pressure on resources leading to lengthy waiting times.  When actually seen, the diagnosis of potential pulmonary embolism, ought to have been recognised as a possible differential diagnosis, eluded both the Emergency Department Practitioner and the Surgical Team member.  Pulmonary embolism should have been considered as a potential cause for her presentation, and had it been so considered, it would have been appropriate to send Lillian for further investigation and to admit her.  There was no clear ownership of the patient whilst she was in Hospital on the 27th, and there was no “safety-netting”.  As a consequence of that and the failure of the various personnel to communicate with each other, Lillian was discharged from Hospital without discussion, without further investigation, and importantly, without any cause being found for her raised infection markers and her shortness of breath.

Had appropriate care been provided to her at that point, then anticoagulation medication would have been prescribed and dispensed to her, thereby preventing her death.

By the time Lillian attended at Hospital on 29th March 2019, whilst care was deficient in that the possibility of pulmonary embolism was never fully considered, by then it was already too late to take action to avoid the death.  The opportunity had been missed two days earlier.

In finding the death to be “preventable”, Coroner Toal recognised that this was a case from which significant learning had been taken, and she noted, with approval, the culture shift as respects issues of patient safety and the significant changes around prevention and diagnosis of clots within the Hospital.  She expressed the hope that the learning would provide comfort to the family of the Deceased that her death had not been in vain, and that many more lives will be saved.

Commenting upon the outcome, Orlagh Diamond, daughter of Lillian, speaking on behalf of the family, noted;-

“From the very beginning we believed mistakes had been made, while mummy was alive, we tried to tell the Doctors just how unwell she was, but we felt we were not listened to.  After mummy died, we were led to believe that everything had been done correctly and that her death was inevitable.  We were expected to accept this and live with our loss.  But we knew something wasn’t right and refused to stop seeking answers.  Seven years later, after fighting to be heard, the Inquest has confirmed what we feared all along: mummy’s death was preventable…Ironically, the very organised that failed our mummy is the very same place that she had dedicated more than 25 years of her life by working as a Catering Manager at Belfast City Hospital.  Mummy was a dedicated member of staff and highly respected by her colleagues from across Belfast.  After giving so much of her working life to the Belfast Trust, when she needed the same organisation to care for her, it horrifically let her down…Mummy was a diamond by nature: strong, resilient, generous, and loved by so many.  She was never just a patient or a name in an Inquest report.  She was our mummy.  She was daddy’s wife and the most amazing granny to her grandchildren.  She was a person whose life mattered enormously.  Her name was Lillian Diamond.  She was precious beyond words, with the most beautiful soul, and she will never be forgotten.  She was our mummy, she should still be here with us today.  Her death was preventable.  She did not have to die”.

  • The image of Lillian accompanying the report is from a painting which is displayed at the Cancer Centre, Belfast Trust, where Lillian worked as a Catering manager for 25 years.
  • Share

Our Healthcare Experts

For further information and advice please contact our experienced legal team.